Coherence of light and interference : students’ reasoning and historical difficulties

Université Paris, France

Supervisor: Laurence Maurines

E-mail: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. 

Abstract

This research examines the difficulties raised by the learning of light interference. Focused on interference of two waves and on the conditions for their production, it concerns three interferential devices (Young’s holes, Fresnel’s mirrors, thin plates) and two types of light (totally or partially coherent). Analyses of the physics of light interference, of its history, of its presentation in university books, and of the studies on conceptions on waves, have been made. Fifteen questionnaires were elaborated. 758 French and Tunisian students (aged 19-23) were questioned after teaching. Several tendencies of reasoning, which are linked together, are put forward. Two are encountered across different domains of physics: focusing on perceptive aspects, diminishing the number of physical quantities that have to be considered. One concerns the difficulties raised by the interpretation of diagrams with parallel rays in optics. Another one is closed to the tendency revealed for diffraction situations: students do not use the wave superposition principle and the interferential device seems modulate the amplitude of the incident wave. The last ones are specific to interference and concern the conditions for their production: for students, it is sufficient to have two point sources or it is necessary to have two monochromatic waves in phase. This research leads to some pedagogical suggestions: to draw diagrams with rays and waves surfaces when explaining the formation of images in order to emphasise that geometrical optics is a particular model derived from the wave theory of light, to reduce all interference situations to the prototypical situation with two sources, to precise the conditions for interference at the beginning of the first lesson

Key Words

University, conceptions, history of optics, light interference, coherence

LDSP, University of Paris 7-ISFEC, University of Tunis

Supervisor :Laurence Maurines

Université Paris-Sud 11, DidaScO, batiment 333, 91405 Orsay cedex,

This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Reference

Romdhane I. & Maurines L. (2003) "Students and the interference of light : first results".
Proceedings of the fourth international conference of ESERA, Noordwijkerhout, on web:
http://www1.phys.uu.nl/esera2003/programme/pdf/192S.pdf

Romdhane I. § Maurines L. (2005) Coherence of light and interference: historical ideas and students’ difficulties. Proceedings of the fifth international conference of ESERA, Barcelone, p. 25, on cd-rom

Correspondence 

Intissar Romdhane
Lycée secondaire de Khniss-5011 Khniss- Tunisie
Tél : +21698965084
Fax : +21673535586
This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. 

Doctor Studies Filter

Subject
Author
From
To

esera 19

ESERA 2019Conference

Visit Esera 2019